• About
    • Ethics policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Ownership, funding and corrections
    • Complaints procedure
    • Terms & Conditions
  • Contact
  • Support
  • Newsletter
Brighton and Hove News
19 November, 2026
  • News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • Opinion
    • Community
  • Arts and Culture
    • Music
    • Theatre
    • Food and Drink
  • Sport
    • Brighton and Hove Albion
    • Cricket
  • Newsletter
  • Public notices
  • Advertise
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • Opinion
    • Community
  • Arts and Culture
    • Music
    • Theatre
    • Food and Drink
  • Sport
    • Brighton and Hove Albion
    • Cricket
  • Newsletter
  • Public notices
  • Advertise
No Result
View All Result
Brighton and Hove News
No Result
View All Result
Home Brighton

Are lessons from Brighton and Hove’s £1m school transport fiasco being ignored?

by Frank le Duc
Monday 15 Jun, 2020 at 1:34PM
A A
2
School transport consultants given £500k contract to cut £300k from service

The council risks repeating the mistakes that led to a £1 million overspend on home to school transport, put children’s safety at risk and left others stranded, according to two senior councillors.

The claim underpins a letter from former council leader Mary Mears and her Conservative colleague Lee Wares to fellow councillors.

They said that almost a year after the chaos and cost overruns that characterised the new service, Brighton and Hove City Council had still not produced a business case.

This oversight – the lack of a business case – was criticised in an independent report by the Local Government Association (LGA) about the changes to the home to school transport service.

Councillor Mears and Councillor Wares said, in a letter to the council’s Children, Young People and Skills Committee, that they welcomed extra money for the service.

But more money did not mean that they no longer had concerns about the transport arrangements for some of Brighton and Hove’s most vulnerable children.

In particular, children at two schools catering for pupils with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) had born the brunt of what was recently described as an “epic failure”. The schools worst affected were Hill Park, in Portslade, and Downs View, in Woodingdean.

Contrary to a decision by senior councillors, officials employed a cost-cutting consultancy, Edge Public Solutions, to scrap traditional four-year contracts.

Instead, contracts for scores of taxi and minibus routes were awarded using a “dynamic purchasing system” which was criticised as being more suitable for ordering stationery than transporting vulnerable children.

Councillor Mears and Councillor Wares said: “While we would not deny the increases to benefit the children and families, these increases were needed to help put right a badly designed and badly procured service.

“A criticism of the LGA was that no business case was produced for the service change. A business case has still not been produced.

“There has been no post-implementation review and no exercise carried out to assess if the service is delivering value for money.

“Increases based on just the budget levels set by other local authorities are meaningless unless there is a review of the absolute detail so that service delivery and procurement can be analysed against cost – not just how much money has been put in the pot.

“There hasn’t been a review to compare the cost of the service before the change versus post the change. Budget increases might have been necessary, but to what level, nobody knows.”

They were also concerned that the extra cash was being spent on a contract arrangement that was rejected by councillors but brought in by officials using “urgency powers”.

These are the same urgency powers that officials are relying on to make quick decisions during the coronavirus crisis.

This made it all the more important for the Labour administration and senior officials to understand what went wrong and how – as well as to identify who was responsible – not least since an internal audit report gave the process a clean bill of health.

Councillor Mears and Councillor Wares said: “Much emphasis has been placed on remedying the problems, and rightly so, (but) there remains the need to investigate why this happened.

“There needs to be culpability that will help rebuild trust and confidence.

“How were delegated powers used? How were contracts with consultants and operators facilitated? How were financial levels complied with?
“And why – when a previous committee report said no to a DPS (dynamic purchasing system) – was one pursued without any work apparently being done on the procurement model that was approved.

“What happened in respect of Edge Public Solutions and the pay-off of £181,000?

“And why did the internal audit differ so fundamentally to the content of the LGA report?

“All these subjects need fully investigating and may, regardless of anything else, determine the way forward.”

Councillor Mary Mears

The two councillors said: “Is the way the service now being delivered the right model? Early thinking is that it is not and that the council sought to fix something that was not broken.

“The change in 2019 was radical but it now requires great effort and bravery to think again.

“A hybrid of pre and post change might be a solution, but a significant influencer is that of political policy.

“The administration needs to quickly decide if it wishes to pursue an in-house solution to rid itself of so-called ‘petty bourgeois monopolies’ or work in partnership with local businesses.

“There is the constant reference to four-year contracts (but) the council can terminate with three months’ notice and the operators giving even less notice.

“There remains the reluctance to accept that operator investment in the infrastructure to deliver the service, such as procuring specialised vehicles, requires a level of contract duration certainty.

“With the history of the problems and the present political direction, that certainty may not exist which places the service at risk.”

Councillor Lee Wares

The two Conservative councillors criticised the council for “scattering reports to various places”, relying on the defence that “time is of the essence”.

They said: “We do acknowledge that covid-19 has had an impact.”

But they added that there were “significant issues around the lack of member involvement” as the council created this “self-inflicted problem”.

And they accused the administration of lacking ambition and “hedging its bets” in aiming to win the trust and confidence of “a mere 80 per cent” of parents and carers.

Another reading of the target was that the council was content that 20 per cent of parents and carers would not have trust and confidence in them.

They said: “Twenty per cent is equal to no trust or confidence affecting 94 children based on 470 being transported.”

The letter from the two councillors is included in the agenda papers for the “virtual” meeting of the council’s Children, Young People and Skills Committee that is due to start at 4pm today (Monday 15 June).

The meeting is scheduled to be webcast on the council’s website.

Support quality, independent, local journalism that matters. Donate here.
ShareTweetShareSendSendShare

Comments 2

  1. Rob Arbery says:
    6 years ago

    Culpability and making either the procedure or person/ persons responsible for this mess is what will give all the parents trust back in the system and that after some apologies from Cllr Allcock this isn’t all swept away and that real and lasting lessons are learnt.

    Reply
  2. Michael Safeen says:
    6 years ago

    I think Home transport services doing a great job a the moment, specially under the covid-19 impact. it showed that the new team dealing with the situation professionally,the budget could be affected to keep social distancing inside transportation. Re-tendering is a bear-trap as the service stabled now The service has been through enough period of turbulence.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Most read

Scores of illegal e-scooter and e-bikes seized in Brighton and Hove

Are lessons from Brighton and Hove’s £1m school transport fiasco being ignored?

Head issues warning about planned international youth strike

Christmas Day buses return for 2026

Councillors to debate i360 ‘lessons learned’ report

Mega holiday let hopes to exploit planning loophole

Venue excluded from Fringe launches alternative festival

Flood defence work gets government cash boost

Head teacher announces departure

Jury retires to decide whether Brighton solicitor is guilty of £500k fraud

Newsletter

Arts and Culture

  • All
  • Music
  • Theatre
  • Food and Drink
Our Newest Old Friend: Dermot Henry Shines at The Prince Albert

Our Newest Old Friend: Dermot Henry Shines at The Prince Albert

17 November 2026
Solve The City - An Outdoor Escape Room in Brighton

Escape In Brighton?

17 November 2026
Long term Fringe venue hits out after being told it can’t return

Venue excluded from Fringe launches alternative festival

17 November 2026

There’s No Such Thing As A Gruffalo?

17 November 2026
Load More

Sport

  • All
  • Brighton and Hove Albion
  • Cricket
Brighton and Hove Albion move up to second after beating Brentford

Brighton and Hove Albion move up to second after beating Brentford

by Frank le Duc
8 November 2026
0

Brighton and Hove Albion 2 Brentford 0 Two first-half goals from Diego Gomez and Pascal Gross gave Brighton and Hove...

Brighton and Hove Albion stick with Etihad victors for Brentford game

Brighton and Hove Albion stick with Etihad victors for Brentford game

by Frank le Duc
8 November 2026
0

Brighton and Hove Albion head coach Fabian Hürzeler has named the same starting line up to face Brentford as he...

Brighton and Hove Albion host Aston Villa in Premier League opener

Brighton and Hove Albion face the ‘A game’ from the Bees

by PA sport staff
7 November 2026
0

Brentford boss Keith Andrews said that his side would need to “bring our A game” to get a result against...

Yalcouye scores only goal as Brighton and Hove Albion beat Getafe

Yalcouye scores only goal as Brighton and Hove Albion beat Getafe

by Andy Sims - PA
5 November 2026
0

Getafe 0 Brighton and Hove Albion 1 Malick Yalcouye fired Brighton and Hove Albion to a 1-0 win in their...

Load More
June 2020
M T W T F S S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930  
« May   Jul »

RSS feed: From Sussex News From Sussex News

  • Jury convicts rapist of more sex attacks 18 November 2026
  • Driver dies in early morning crash 18 November 2026
  • House fire prompts warning about running appliances overnight 18 November 2026
  • Man arrested after siege 18 November 2026
  • Man raped woman in alleyway, court told 17 November 2026
ADVERTISEMENT
  • About
  • Contact
  • Support
  • Newsletter
  • Privacy
  • Complaints
  • Ownership, funding and corrections
  • Ethics
  • T&C

© 2023 Brighton and Hove News

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Opinion
  • Arts and Culture
    • Music
    • Theatre
  • Sport
    • Cricket
  • Newsletter
  • Public notices
  • Advertise
  • About
  • Contact

© 2023 Brighton and Hove News