Objections to the council’s secondary school admissions changes have been partially upheld by the Office of the Schools Adjudicator.
As a result, Brighton and Hove City Council is required to change its admissions rules accordingly when allocating places for next September.
The ruling by schools adjudicator David Holland followed objections by four anonymous parents although one fell outside the deadline.
Some of their objections were upheld. Mr Holland said that the rule giving priority to children eligible for free school meals was “unclear” after a change in the criteria.
But the council’s plan to allocate places to children living outside a catchment area if they have a brother or sister at a school – known as the sibling link – would remain.
Earlier this year, in January, Labour and Green councillors voted through various changes to the secondary school admissions rules for children due to start year 7 in September 2027.
Two of the objectors said that extending sibling links without any restrictions would be unfair after the council introduced a 5 per cent “open admission” criterion from September this year.
This change had already diluted the priority for pupils living in a school’s catchment area.
One of the two parents also said that the rule prioritising children who were eligible for free school meals was unclear. It was expected to ensure that schools had a more even share of these pupils.
Mr Holland said that the criterion, which applied when schools were oversubscribed, was not clear after a change in government policy enabled more children to qualify for free school meals since the start of the current school year.
Previously free school meals were offered to children where families had an income lower than £7,400 but, since September, it has included all households receiving universal credit.
The free school meals criterion would apply only to those who received “targeted” free school meals – with a family income of less than £7,400 a year – rather than to all those eligible for free school meals.
The Schools Admissions Code states that an admissions authority, such as the council, must maintain a clear, fair and objective waiting list until at least 31 December of each school year, ranked in line with the over-subscription criteria.
Mr Holland said: “While admission authorities may seek confirmation that parents wish to remain on a waiting list, I do not consider the code permits an arrangement under which unsuccessful applicants are excluded from the waiting list unless they actively opt in.”
The council had argued that the code only specified that a waiting list needed to be held and had hoped to exclude children whose parents or carers die not opt in to the list.
Mr Holland ruled that the council’s waiting list arrangements “lacked sufficient clarity” and did not conform to the requirements and that automatic withdrawal was inconsistent with the admissions code.
Councillor Jacob Taylor, the Labour deputy leader of the council, said: “We welcome the adjudicator’s decisions and are pleased that our approach to expanding the sibling link for all pupils regardless of catchment area has been upheld.
“This reflects our commitment to tackling inequality, creating greater equity of opportunity and improving educational outcomes – work that has been recognised by the Sutton Trust’s Fair School Admissions Gold Award for two consecutive years.
“We also welcome the clarity provided regarding the application of our free school meals criteria.
“The way free school meals are allocated changed after we announced this policy and we agree that our admissions must reflect the national system.
“The determination also means we’ll be reviewing how we propose to manage pupils on waiting lists for secondary schools across the city.
“We’re currently considering the full details of the adjudicator’s decision and we’ll be addressing this by Saturday 31 October (the closing date for secondary school place applications) and amending our admissions arrangements accordingly.”









This is now the third year in a row that councillors have made changes to the secondary school admissions arrangements. Brighton and Hove now has incredibly complex arrangements, which parents are finding hard to understand.
This year the adjudicator highlighted many errors, including wrong dates and different versions of the rules. The council also tried to change how waiting lists operate so that parents would have had to actively opt in. That went against what local people said in the consultation and against the statutory Admissions Code, and the adjudicator has overturned it.
Most worryingly, when the national rules on free school meals changed, the council tried to change the priority for these children through its guidance rather than the admission arrangements. According to the council, around 44% of children who previously qualified no longer will. I’m not sure that is something for Cllr Taylor to be celebrating.
These relentless changes have divided our communities, yet no evaluation of them has been published. Instead, the council is publishing fewer details than it did before on how places have been allocated.
Parents deserve stable, clear rules, not a new experiment from Councillors every year.
So the adjudicator required clarification on the definition of free school meals placements, and waiting lists to be opt-out. Cllr. Taylor, representing BHCC, agreed they would comply. A transactional story.