The former deputy mayor of Brighton and Hove has appealed against a council standards panel ruling after he was found to have touched the former mayor inappropriately as they posed for a photograph.
Councillor Ty Galvin denied the claim which was made by Councillor Amanda Grimshaw after they posed for a photograph at a Sussex University graduation ceremony together in July last year.
The Brighton and Hove City Council standards panel, made up of three councillors and an independent chair, considered the findings of an investigation by Kirsty Cole, a solicitor at Bevan Brittan, on Friday 30 October.
The panel found that Councillor Galvin had breached the council’s code of conduct for councillors by touching the former mayor inappropriately and by making inappropriate comments to other women.
The grounds for appeal include a claim that the standards panel hearing was procedurally flawed and that it broke the fundamental rules of natural justice.
Councillor Galvin is understood to have claimed that there was no chance for anyone to question any witnesses, including the former mayor, at the standards panel hearing because none of them attended.
He also claims that the external investigating officer instructed by the council strayed from the best-practice guidance for standards panel hearings issued by the Local Government Association.
In particular, she is alleged to have discarded or destroyed her handwritten interview notes that formed the basis of witness statements that she drafted for sign-off by the individuals concerned.
Councillor Galvin said that statements presented to the panel were inadequate and incorrect summaries of her witness interviews but, because the handwritten interview notes were discarded or destroyed, they could not be provided to the former deputy mayor.
It is also claimed that a relevant consideration was not taken into account by the standards panel but that irrelevant considerations were taken into account.
Councillor Galvin added that new information had since come to light with a direct and significant bearing on the allegations made against him and that, in any event, the standards panel’s decision was irrational and unreasonable.
In line with the council’s procedures for dealing with standards complaints, Councillor Galvin is seeking a second hearing by a panel made up of different members to consider the matter afresh.
If the council refuses, it is open to Councillor Galvin to apply to the Administrative Division of the High Court for a judicial review on the grounds of illegality, irrationality or procedural unfairness.







The fact Cllr Grimshaw, as the accuser, failed to attend the Standards meeting convened to address the allegation.
Cllr Galvin was denied the right to question witnesses.
Statements appear to have been taken into consideration from friends of Cllr Grimshaw, concerning alleged behavioural incidents, which had never been submitted as formal complaints.
The meeting was held secretly against the express wish of Cllr Galvin who had asked for the proceedings to be both public and transparent.
Taken cumulatively, these factors should automatically invalidate the meeting and its verdict, as they most certainly would a court case.