• About
    • Ethics policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Ownership, funding and corrections
    • Complaints procedure
    • Terms & Conditions
  • Contact
  • Support
  • Newsletter
Brighton and Hove News
19 November, 2026
  • News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • Opinion
    • Community
  • Arts and Culture
    • Music
    • Theatre
    • Food and Drink
  • Sport
    • Brighton and Hove Albion
    • Cricket
  • Newsletter
  • Public notices
  • Advertise
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • Opinion
    • Community
  • Arts and Culture
    • Music
    • Theatre
    • Food and Drink
  • Sport
    • Brighton and Hove Albion
    • Cricket
  • Newsletter
  • Public notices
  • Advertise
No Result
View All Result
Brighton and Hove News
No Result
View All Result
Home Brighton

Councillors to debate i360 ‘lessons learned’ report

by Sarah Booker-Lewis - local democracy reporter
Tuesday 17 Nov, 2026 at 11:35PM
A A
21
Council books further £2.5m loss on Brighton i360 debt

Brighton i360

A long-awaited “lessons learned” report into Brighton and Hove City Council’s loan to the i360 is due to go before councillors next week.

The report, by the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA), was due to go before the council’s Audit, Standards and General Purposes Committee in April but was withdrawn.

Labour councillor Liz Loughran called on Green councillor Pete West, who chairs the committee, to allow members to debate the report.

But Councillor West said in April that he felt the report was incomplete because it had been written without contacting those involved in the original decision in 2014 to broker a £36 million loan from the Public Works Loan Board to the i360 developer Marks Barfield.

At the June meeting of the committee, Labour councillor Josh Guilmant said that the delay in bringing the report before the committee was “shameful”.

Councillor West said that “shameful” was a strong word but, after taking advice, accepted that the report should be on the agenda in September.

However, the September meeting was postponed so the report is now scheduled to receive public scrutiny at a meeting of the committee at Hove Town Hall next Tuesday (24 November).

The CIPFA report, which cost £5,000 to produce, said that the council was sold “over-ambitious” projections of visitor numbers, revenues and profits.

The council kept the business case secret from the public when Green and some Conservative councillors approved the £36 million loan to Marks Barfield, citing commercial confidentiality.

Brighton and Hove City Council is paying off the loan at £2.2 million a year until 2041 and still owes about £30 million.

When the Brighton i360 company went into administration just before Christmas 2024, it owed the council £51 million.

Of that sum, almost £19 million consisted of interest on the loan and other money owed to the council and a further £32 million which the council in turn owed to the government’s Public Works Loan Board.

The report said that the council agreed to broker the loan at a time when councils were being encouraged to “think commercially” by the government and to borrow at low interest rates from the Public Works Loan Board.

A business plan for the i360 included projected annual visitor numbers of 800,000 in the first year, then 700,000 a year. It needed 332,500 to be financially viable.

In reality, it attracted 500,000 people in its first full year and, overall, averaged about 270,000 a year before going bust almost two years ago.

While the business plan looked at regional attractions when forecasting visitor numbers, it also included global landmarks such as the London Eye, Eiffel Tower and Empire State Building.

The report said: “These international comparators operate at a scale and within destination markets that bear little resemblance to the local regional context.

“The approach should have primarily focused on benchmarking against domestic attractions such as the Spinnaker Tower, in Portsmouth, Blackpool Tower and Sea Life Brighton.”

Financial projections were also “overly ambitious”, with £11.7 million in revenue and £6.7 million in earnings before interest, taxes and depreciation.

The report said: “The i360 struggled to break even and eventually defaulted on its loans.

“As well as visitor numbers, a further key issue was the overestimation of revenue per visitor and secondary spending, such as purchases at the Sky Bar and merchandise sales.

“The expected conversion rates and spending levels did not materialise, undermining the financial viability of the project.

“The Brighton i360 business plan demonstrated optimism bias, a common cognitive and planning pitfall in large infrastructure and public sector projects.”

Recommendations for future projects include applying optimism bias adjustments, modelling best-case and worst-case scenarios, using multiple sources to validate demand and pricing and using data and social media analysis to gauge market appetite for a project.

The council’s Audit, Standards and General Purposes Committee is due to meet at Hove Town Hall at 4pm next Tuesday (24 November). The meeting is scheduled to be webcast.

Support quality, independent, local journalism that matters. Donate here.
ShareTweetShareSendSendShare

Comments 21

  1. Bear Road Resident says:
    19 hours ago

    No wonder Pete West wants to try and bury this report. Isn’t having a ‘green ‘the party who instigated this massive disaster, rather too much like having a poacher In charge of reviewing poaching.

    Reply
    • Dick Page says:
      8 hours ago

      But a balanced investigation WOULD have interviewed the decision-makers of the time.

      Reply
  2. JamesK says:
    18 hours ago

    The Greens approved the £36m loan from the public purse to construct the i360.
    Labour then constructed the i360, rather than binning it as a terrible idea with no sound business plan, and ignoring all public opposition pointing this out.
    Now Labour intends to borrow £47m towards an overpriced, suboptimal £65m leisure centre project with no sound business plan, which removes many family leisure and community facilities, ignoring all public opposition to it, no lesssons learned.

    Reply
    • Bear Road Resident says:
      16 hours ago

      The erection of the I360 took place between 2014 and 2016 and, according to the Brighton & Hove City Council Annual Council Agenda (15 May 2014), the political composition of the 54-seat council in 2014 was 21 Green, 18 Conservative, 14 Labour & Co-operative, and 1 Independent.

      Reply
    • Caroline Penn says:
      16 hours ago

      Wow. Talk about re-writing history. This is total misinformation.

      It was already a done deal with the Local Economic Partnership in 2014, and work actually started in May 2014.

      By the time the election was held in 2015, the foundations were built and the tower sections were on their way from Holland.

      As a former Labour Councillor from 2015, I can categorically state this was on the Greens and at no point did any of the Green councillors still around today speak against it.

      Reply
      • Dick Page says:
        8 hours ago

        You can categorically state what you like. You know Labour was involved in the project.
        People are tired of all the political pointscoring.

        Reply
        • Katy says:
          7 hours ago

          They’re not tired at all and you don’t speak for us. The Greens messed up, showed economic naivety and have tried to avoid scrutiny. On all three counts, they should never be elected again.
          They have cost this city and us residents millions. Any good will I had to them has gone.

          Reply
  3. Juno Imright says:
    18 hours ago

    I thought Marks Barfield was the husband and wife architectural practice who designed it?
    I’m not a chartered accountant but in 30 years of commercial property projects letting the architect be the developer would be a rather large mistake.
    Architects design and project managers / cost consultants manage costs and budgets.

    Reply
  4. Dave the rave says:
    17 hours ago

    Where’s Benjamin? His ‘expertise’ in everything under the sun (or under a news article) is dearly missed.

    Reply
  5. MaxineM says:
    17 hours ago

    If this is Labour trying to stitch up the Greens pre-election, it doesn’t take much googling to find Labour were equally responsible for the i360 being built. People might also expect proof that the current Labour administration has learned the lessons it is trying to rub the Greens’ face in and can be trusted with major borrowing for the delivery of world beating projects with bulletproof business plans.

    Reply
    • Caroline Penn says:
      15 hours ago

      I honestly don’t know what you are googling but it’s been covered numerous times. The Policy and Resources meeting was held in public and reported on and is still BHCC’s website. It was a Public Works Loan taken out with the Local Economic Partnership.

      The Greens and Conservatives voted for it, Labour voted against.

      It’s really disturbing the amount of misinformation that’s being shared when this is a matter of public record.

      Reply
      • Katy says:
        7 hours ago

        Well said Caroline. The trolls are out trying to massage their spin on the truth.

        Reply
        • JamesK says:
          3 hours ago

          Name the heroes in this situation, Katy. Labour are up to their neck in repeatedly bailing out this failed attraction at public expense, even if the Greens signed off the original cost. Why can’t the i360 be allowed to fail and how long is this ludicrous situation propping it up going to be allowed to carry on? The debts don’t stop with pretending to write them off and then starting a new losses sheet with Sarah Willingham, who will doubtless also try and get her debts written off when she finally throws in the towel, which is only a matter of time. The future needs to be analysed at this Standards and Audit meeting as well as the past.

          Reply
  6. Ann E Nicky says:
    14 hours ago

    Before they launch the destruction of King Alfred and disposal of the land, could we please apply these “lessons learned” and produce a correct forecast and analysis. The proposals are not fit for purpose and do not promote wide appeal and access. The coffee shop looks good though!

    Reply
    • Tracy Ward says:
      14 hours ago

      When a project business plan is regarded as top secret by a public body council, that is one massive RED FLAG which should halt everything until the council offer full transparency. In the case of the King Alfred, they aren’t even being honest about the whole site plan and have admitted £65m may not be the final cost – presumably for the leisure hub only, but we don’t even know that. And now the housing market is in freefall so any tower blocks built risk remaining empty for years.

      Reply
  7. Tracy Ward says:
    14 hours ago

    “Brighton & Hove City Council’s Labour group (and Labour & Co-operative group) backed the Brighton i360 project during its planning and early loan stages in 2006 and 2012, before opposing the increased public loan package in 2014.”
    Yet Labour still didn’t stop this utter turkey being built and ended up enabling it and even propping it up over the years by deferring loan and rent repayments and selling it to former Dragon’s Den star Sarah Willingham for peanuts – £150k in 2025 – only requiring 1% annual revenue share each year in return, after the i360 went into administration with a £51m debt. Why? And when will Ms Willingham start paying this annual 1% to the council?
    The i360 is a commercial failure which is not being allowed to die, but instead is being kept alive with an artificial life support machine supplied by LABOUR, who are equally to blame for this fiasco. No doubt all the other private businesses in Brighton would love to have the same council support to keep their businesses open, no matter what, but the i360 gets the full benefit of Labour claiming to support local businesses. This could open them to legal challenge from unsupported local businesses receiving no perks, rent or business rate holidays.

    Reply
  8. Stan Reid says:
    12 hours ago

    And this “debate” is going to cost how much ??

    Reply
  9. Rostrum says:
    6 hours ago

    I do hope a copy has been sent to the Police and Home Office. There may be criminality that should be addressed…

    Reply
  10. Lady Bracknell says:
    4 hours ago

    Lady Bracknell is delighted to see such enthusiasm for scrutinising the commercial decisions of previous administrations. One trusts Labour will apply precisely the same rigour to its own handling of the i360’s collapse and subsequent sale.

    In particular, will councillors be examining the commercial terms of the sale, the decision to write off tens of millions of pounds of debt, and whether the transaction genuinely represented the best possible value for Brighton and Hove taxpayers?

    Lessons learned are terribly important, of course. But they are rather less convincing when the scrutiny extends only to the decisions of one’s predecessors.

    Reply
  11. Dog lover says:
    4 hours ago

    Kin Jason Kitcat!

    Reply
  12. Carol Carter says:
    4 hours ago

    Brighton Labour really are becoming rather tiresome. So much energy devoted to pointing fingers at the Tories and Greens, and so little evidence of any imagination, inspiration or achievements of their own.

    Bella and Jacob, together with their browbeaten lackeys, seem to have mistaken endlessly rehearsing the failings of previous administrations for actually running the city. It’s all rather like watching two self-important school prefects bullying everyone else over their homework, while having absolutely nothing of their own to hand in.

    Perhaps they’d be better off spending a little less time slagging off the opposition and a little more time trying to hold on to their own councillors!

    Brighton deserves rather more than this dreary political pantomime.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Most read

Scores of illegal e-scooter and e-bikes seized in Brighton and Hove

Head issues warning about planned international youth strike

Councillors to debate i360 ‘lessons learned’ report

Christmas Day buses return for 2026

Councillors to debate i360 ‘lessons learned’ report

Mega holiday let hopes to exploit planning loophole

Venue excluded from Fringe launches alternative festival

Flood defence work gets government cash boost

Head teacher announces departure

Pedestrian hit by car on A259

Newsletter

Arts and Culture

  • All
  • Music
  • Theatre
  • Food and Drink
Our Newest Old Friend: Dermot Henry Shines at The Prince Albert

Our Newest Old Friend: Dermot Henry Shines at The Prince Albert

17 November 2026
Solve The City - An Outdoor Escape Room in Brighton

Escape In Brighton?

17 November 2026
Long term Fringe venue hits out after being told it can’t return

Venue excluded from Fringe launches alternative festival

17 November 2026

There’s No Such Thing As A Gruffalo?

17 November 2026
Load More

Sport

  • All
  • Brighton and Hove Albion
  • Cricket
Brighton and Hove Albion move up to second after beating Brentford

Brighton and Hove Albion move up to second after beating Brentford

by Frank le Duc
8 November 2026
0

Brighton and Hove Albion 2 Brentford 0 Two first-half goals from Diego Gomez and Pascal Gross gave Brighton and Hove...

Brighton and Hove Albion stick with Etihad victors for Brentford game

Brighton and Hove Albion stick with Etihad victors for Brentford game

by Frank le Duc
8 November 2026
0

Brighton and Hove Albion head coach Fabian Hürzeler has named the same starting line up to face Brentford as he...

Brighton and Hove Albion host Aston Villa in Premier League opener

Brighton and Hove Albion face the ‘A game’ from the Bees

by PA sport staff
7 November 2026
0

Brentford boss Keith Andrews said that his side would need to “bring our A game” to get a result against...

Yalcouye scores only goal as Brighton and Hove Albion beat Getafe

Yalcouye scores only goal as Brighton and Hove Albion beat Getafe

by Andy Sims - PA
5 November 2026
0

Getafe 0 Brighton and Hove Albion 1 Malick Yalcouye fired Brighton and Hove Albion to a 1-0 win in their...

Load More
November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  
« Oct    

RSS feed: From Sussex News From Sussex News

  • Jury convicts rapist of more sex attacks 18 November 2026
  • Driver dies in early morning crash 18 November 2026
  • House fire prompts warning about running appliances overnight 18 November 2026
  • Man arrested after siege 18 November 2026
  • Man raped woman in alleyway, court told 17 November 2026
ADVERTISEMENT
  • About
  • Contact
  • Support
  • Newsletter
  • Privacy
  • Complaints
  • Ownership, funding and corrections
  • Ethics
  • T&C

© 2023 Brighton and Hove News

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Opinion
  • Arts and Culture
    • Music
    • Theatre
  • Sport
    • Cricket
  • Newsletter
  • Public notices
  • Advertise
  • About
  • Contact

© 2023 Brighton and Hove News