A residents’ association has raised concerns about how future residents of a proposed affordable housing scheme in central Brighton will cope from noise from the scrap metal company underneath.
Developer QED has applied to Brighton and Hove City Council for outline permission to build 66 affordable flats in a 12-storey block on the corner plot at 53 New England Street and 10 New England Road.
The site, known as Richardson’s Yard, is currently occupied by 36 shipping container homes operated by BHT Sussex and the Geo E Richardson and Sons scrap metal business.
The application would provide 30, one-bedroom flats, 32 two-bedroom and four three-bedroom homes as well as 852 square metres of commercial space, with 464 square metres being kept for the metal recycling company on the ground floor.
The planning statement by QED’s agent Lewis and Co Planning Limited, said: “Notwithstanding that the scheme is submitted in outline only, it is clear that the proposed development will provide for a high standard of accommodation for future residents.
“Given that the scheme is for 100 per cent affordable housing, and so provides access to housing for people and families who might otherwise struggle to fund good quality accommodation, this cannot be underestimated.”
There are nine objections on Brighton and Hove City Council’s planning website, many raising concerns about the building’s height and the metal recycling facility being directly below homes.
A West Hill and North Laine ward councillors whose name is removed on the council website but is either Sue Shanks or Ellen McLeay, said when the council approved the land deal in 2021, the scheme was up to eight stories.
The Green councillor said: “There is also insufficient clarity regarding the affordable housing offer.
“Although the application refers to ‘100 per cent affordable housing’, yet I cannot find an affordable housing statement, a tenure schedule, a legally secured social rent commitment, a named registered provider, or draft Section 106 agreement confirming what will be delivered.”
Jack Zeniewski, chair of the Brighton Greenway Residents’ Association said: “We support affordable housing on this site. But putting homes directly above a working metal-recycling yard and then relying on residents keeping their windows closed to deal with the noise raises a serious question about the standard of housing being offered.
“And if it’s being described as ‘100 per cent affordable’, the council should be clear about what that actually means and whether these will be social-rent homes. Affordable housing shouldn’t mean second-rate housing.”
A comment with the user details redacted on the council’s website, said: “As a resident living directly opposite the site in the New England Quarter for 17 years, I am deeply concerned by the severe massing of this 12-storey proposal.
“Crucially, while the building is 12 storeys overall, several lower floors sit below or level with my flat, meaning seven full storeys will tower directly upward from my eye-line.
“This aggressive, cliff-like vertical wall will block natural light, plunging my living spaces, bedroom, and balcony into deep shadow and destroying my open sky view.”
The application is available to view by searching for BH2026/01773 on the council’s planning website.








100% affordable, keeping the business that’s currently there and building high where it won’t affect others, redevelopment of possibly one of the biggest eyesores in the city. Be moronical not to instantly approve it.
It would be idiotic to approve such a scheme. A complete overdevelopment that would impact on the business and neighbours without any of the necessary guarantees and commitments.
Seeing as they have agreement from said business, clearly you are talking from your behind again. If you look across the road to York and eldar, this is tiny in comparison so not at all an overdevelopment. Currently the site is shipping container housing so… Id argue this is a massive improvement. But then ann you just like to moan about everything from an unlogical stand point so I’m sorting of banging my head against a brick wall talking to you. It feels like I’m talking to a green councillor tbh…
Congratulations Ms Hogwash, it appears it is you that is harking to the past – unlogical fell out of common usagee many years ago!
My main gripes are that there are no binding agreements in place thus it is speculation that this would ease any housing crisis, just displace some social tenants.
The proposed development would place those opposite in shade & the footprint is rather small to house that many units.
The business may agree to this because it will make it easier to get change of use for their premises thus increasing the value of the land.
I do care about the built environment, especially in the place where I was born, raised & reside. I have no political affiliation just a concern about the direction where Society is heading when corporate greed trumps true, long-term progress for all.
Affordable means at 80% of the market rate. Is that affordable?
Good, hopefully will be approved. More affordable is needed. Also make that corner neat and tidy.
I assume those in favour in the comments don’t live next door to it and wont be constantly shaded by the monstrosity. Perhaps think how it would affect you if it was proposed in front of your home. Yes, it’s my comment they’ve quoted at the end, and there’s more opposing comments on the planning website than this article says there is.
Nobody lives next door to it…
100% affordable homes – this still usually equates to 80% of the open market value, which for most first time buyers is still way out of their budget range in Brighton. As for the noise, I don’t suppose the train line running behind it will generate any noise… 🙂
Does anyone want leasehold flats any more ? I keep getting told that nobody wants them. Plenty for sale in Brighton and Hove that are not selling today.
I thought “leasehold” terms had changed for new builds ??
I cycle past the metal recycling units every day, have sold scrap to them, and never known them to be noisy. Certainly quieter than the 3 lanes of traffic and the train line.