Restaurant Review: Connie’s Pizza, Brighton
There are few restaurant critics harder to please than a hungry teenager. So when my pint-sized dining companion declared that the pizza at Connie’s was the best he had ever eaten, I knew Brighton’s newest pizzeria was doing something right.

We visited Connie’s Pizza in Gardner Street earlier this week, in the heart of the North Laine, Brighton for an early evening meal. We were both recovering from a virus and feeling a little below par, so this was a fairly low-key outing. Fortunately, the food did much of the heavy lifting.
Connie’s is the latest venture from Naples-born pizzaiolo Andrea Asciuti, the man behind 081 Pizzeria. Having opened its first restaurant in Peckham in South London earlier this year, the independent business has brought its New York-inspired, thin and crispy pizzas to Brighton, combining Italian pizza-making know-how with a relaxed neighbourhood-pizzeria approach. The name comes from Andrea’s wife, Connie. She’s Italian too, they met in the UK. Andrea makes the pizza, Connie makes it feel like home.
We began with the pork meatballs in marinara sauce (£9), which my son ordered with the sort of determination usually reserved for securing the last seat on a school bus. Getting him to share was something of a challenge, but I can confirm that these were superb. The homemade meatballs sat neatly in a beautifully crafted tomato sauce, accompanied by artisan bread for mopping up every last bit. It was a simple dish executed with care, and a very good start. He wolfed down the lot. These are really to be commended as they were well-crafted and incredibly tasty.

I opted for the mozzarella sticks (£7), served in a basket with tomato sauce. These were tremendous fun to eat. We are told not to play with our food, but there is something irresistibly entertaining about taking a bite of a mozzarella stick and pulling the two halves apart to see just how far the cheese will stretch. Pretty far! Enough to make the table next to us laugh. Happily, they tasted every bit as good as they looked, with a crisp coating giving way to gooey mozzarella. There are other options to choose from too, including cheesy dough balls and a radicchio salad, or deep fried mac n cheese.
To wash it all down, my son chose a San Pellegrino Limonata for a bargain £3, while I had half a pint of Harbour Singlefin lager (£4), a traditional German-style lager brewed in Cornwall from Unbarred Brewery. Light on the tongue and easy to drink, it was a good accompaniment to the food. A pint of it costs £7.

Then came the main event, and this is where Connie’s really came into its own. The prices are spectacularly affordable. The Mary Nara, the cheapest pizza on the menu, costs just £6. That is some special late-stage capitalism pricing. At a time when eating out can feel like a luxury reserved for those with disposable income to spare, Connie’s makes a proper meal accessible to a much wider audience. The restaurant was consistently busy throughout our midweek visit, from 6.30pm onwards, suggesting that Brighton diners appreciate the proposition.

I chose the house special, the Brighton Special, also known as the Clam Pie (£12). This white pizza, or pizza bianca, features clams, mozzarella, pecorino Romano, oregano, parsley and garlic. I had never tried a clam pizza before, but this was a marvel. The clams are sourced fresh locally each day, and the combination of seafood, cheese and herbs worked beautifully against a light, crispy crust.
There is a deftness of touch here that speaks volumes about the person making the food. This is a chef who knows his dough, understands how flavours work together, and has the confidence to let good ingredients speak for themselves. The Brighton Special feels genuinely distinctive rather than a novelty concocted simply to attract attention. It is a seaside-inspired pizza that makes sense in its setting.
My son chose the Double Pepperoni and Honey, which would not have been my own first choice, but I was graciously permitted to sample it. I am very glad I did. Tomato sauce, mozzarella, spicy pepperoni, hot honey, basil, Grana Padano and extra virgin olive oil combine in a riot of flavour. The honey tempers the heat and richness of the meat, adding a subtle sweetness without overwhelming the other ingredients. It is an excellent example of how a seemingly simple combination can be so much more than the sum of its parts.

There are ten pizzas to choose from on this compact menu, all made fresh to order on the premises. The star of the show, jostling for position with those marvellous meatballs, is the crispy base. These are not the thick, doughy affairs that dominate many mainstream pizza restaurants. Connie’s bases are thin, light and properly crisp, providing a satisfying crunch without competing with the toppings.
If you have not tried this style of pizza, you really should. It offers a different approach to the familiar form, and the quality of the base makes a considerable difference to the finished dish.
The menu also includes indulgent desserts, although we let the side down on that front. Having demolished our starters and mains, neither of us could contemplate a third course. Our recent bout of flu had clearly done nothing to improve our capacity for gluttony.
If you have more room than we did, you can choose a fiocco di neve, a soft mini brioche filled with whipped ricotta cream, Nutella or pistachio at £6 each, or a New York cheesecake topped with strawberry or salted caramel sauce at £7 for a slice. I shall have to return to investigate these properly.

Connie’s also offers pizza slices to take away, with the front of the restaurant dedicated to those dropping in for a quick bite. It is a welcome option if you are passing through the North Laine and fancy sampling a flavour without committing to a whole pizza.
The food is only part of the appeal. The waiting staff were polite and charming, and the central location makes Connie’s an easy stop for shoppers, theatre-goers and anyone exploring Brighton. The atmosphere was lively, with a steady stream of diners enjoying what feels like a refreshingly straightforward proposition: good pizza, well-made food, friendly service and prices that do not require a second mortgage.
Considering Connie’s has only been open for a couple of weeks, it already feels as though it has found its feet. It is independent, confident in its food and refreshingly unpretentious. There is no need to dress up a pizza restaurant as something it is not when the quality of the cooking does the talking.
My son has already delivered his verdict, declaring his Double Pepperoni and Honey the best pizza he has ever eaten. I am inclined to agree that Connie’s is doing something rather special, although my own allegiance currently rests with the Brighton Special and those crispy bases.
I am delighted that Andrea Asciuti has chosen Brighton for his second restaurant after Peckham. This Neapolitan has brought something distinctive to the North Laine, with a menu that combines culinary skill with genuine affordability.
Brighton, make room at the table. Connie’s is well worth a visit.
Details
Opening Times: Connie’s Pizza in Brighton is open Sunday through Thursday from 11:30 AM to 10:00 PM, and Friday through Saturday from 11:30 AM to 11:00 PM.
Pricing: Whole pizzas cost between £6 and £12 (such as an £8 Margherita and a £12 Brighton-exclusive clam pie).
Venue: Connie’s Pizza, 44-47 Gardner Street, Brighton, BN1 1UN.
Find more arts and culture reviews at Brighton and Hove News – Follow @BHCitywhatson and @bhcitynews on Instagram.
Covering everything from fringe theatre to major tours across Brighton and Hove – tag us if you’re going









Too many pizza places about and it’s not a meal to me
I tried it yesterday and I have to say it is nothing like other pizzas in Brighton, as Fatto e Mano is Neapolitan style, as is VIP and Rudy’s, though they all have differences, so the ‘too many pizza places’ thing isn’t necessarily correct. You could make a case that Pizza Express is ‘1968 Swinging London Pizza’ (in fact they need to seriously define that if they are to survive).
Connie’s Pizza is most definitely unapologetically New York, with an oily crust from the dense cheese that they use (it was robust and strong), and I think olive oil in the dough, and it doesn’t have the stretch and pillowy nature of Neapolitan, but is thin and rips apart. It’s tough so you can walk and eat. So what it does is something else entirely from the other places. What we don’t have in Brighton is Chicago pizza, and thank God for that.
You might say they are all just pizza, but I’d say that about curry. All curries taste the same to me.
Sometimes you want New York pizza, especially daytime, on the go, by the slice, and that is what this is, and why it works so well as a variant, especially here on Gardner Street with tons of people of the right demographic passing by. The location is perfection, and anywhere else it may not fit quite so well.
I thought it was excellent, but if you don’t understand the context, history, the food-culture, or travel much and eat pizza across Italy and the USA, then you just wouldn’t get it. I do, and I do.
Another rabbit hole would be Subway (mostly overlooked) – why it is called Subway, which relates to the BMT sandwich, being the New York transport system (Brooklyn Manhattan Transit), and the whole backstory. Go watch the movie Founder and then see what you think of McDonald’s. Go look up what Coca-Cola did for Martin Luther King and the Civil Rights Movement.
Understanding modern food culture, how these things began and the influence they have, is a seriously entertaining and fascinating subject.
“Too many pizza places about”? Nah.. you don’t get it. Dig a bit, and you will. I urge you to.