Brighton and Hove licensing policy likened to ‘prohibition’

The council’s alcohol licensing policy was likened to “prohibition” by a new delivery company applying for a 24-hour licence.

Getir wants to be able to deliver alcoholic drinks around the clock from its Hove depot but Brighton and Hove City Council would normally expect new “off-licences” to close by 11pm.

Getir started operating from St Joseph’s Business Park, in St Joseph’s Mews, off Old Shoreham Road, Hove, last month, offering grocery delivery within minutes through its app.

Its application for a 24-7 drinks licence went before a council licensing panel earlier today (Thursday 5 August).

Sussex Police licensing officer Hannah Staplehurst said that the force was concerned about potential deliveries to the central areas of Brighton and Hove.

The council has more restrictive policies in the central areas because of a “saturation” of licensed premises and high levels of alcohol-related crime and anti-social behaviour.

She told the virtual licensing panel hearing: “This area suffers from high crime and disorder and could include delivery 24 hours a day to party houses and Airbnbs within the city, which will see an increase in anti-social behaviour.

“Sussex Police also have concerns about the negative impact this will have on the city’s night-time economy and fears alcohol deliveries to residential properties will lead to a pull on our resources by encouraging already intoxicated persons to continue drinking, increasing their intoxication levels making them vulnerable to crime or likely to commit crime.”

Getir’s licensing consultant Chris Nixon, of Knight Training, said that the policy was designed for shops where customers visit in person, not people enjoying a drink delivered to their own home.

Mr Nixon told the panel of three councillors – Lizzie Deane, Dee Simson and Carol Theobald – that there was no link between delivering alcohol to people at home and high crime levels.

He said: “If you agree with the arguments put forward to you to refuse the licence, this is the prohibition of alcohol to Brighton’s residents.

“If you agree to restrict hours based on the evidence and the cases put before you, this is a restriction on the supply of alcohol forcibly against a particular business to a geographical area.

“There is no other word for it than prohibition. This is not what the Licensing Act is for.”

Councillor Theobald asked about deliveries to party houses.

Mr Nixon said that he did not recognise the term “party house” and told the panel that the law allows a retailer to carry out a “responsible and legal sale” to people who are sober and can prove they are over 18.

The company operated a “Challenge 25” policy, he said.

He added that the most popular item in its late-night delivery service was milk and, later at night, the core customers were people who worked in the emergency services and other shift workers.

Getir’s customers were required to include their date of birth and address before they could place an order, he said, while the company also restricted deliveries to home and business addresses only.

It employed its own drivers who were paid a salary, rather than working in the “gig” economy, and they were not given incentives or bonuses for speedy deliveries.

The panel retired to make its decision which should be made public within five working days.

  1. Chris Reply

    Perhaps people need to start thinking ahead again instead of expecting to get anything they want (not necessarily need) at any time. Deliveries in the early hours of the morning are potentially going to be disruptive to other residents. I#m glad there is more flexibility in shopping hours, compared to the years when everything closed for several days on major holidays, but is 24/7/365 really necessary apart from money making?

  2. Bear Road resident Reply

    To liken the council’s refusal to allow this 24 hour alcohol delivery service to prohibition is just hyperbolic nonsense.
    Within twenty minutes walk of my house there over a dozen establishments where one may purchase alcohol from early in the morning until quite late at night and anyone who can’t manage to purchase what they need in that time needs to consider their time management issues. Also, as Chris has pointed out, there are already a substantial number of these delivery bikes roaring about the streets at all hours.

  3. David Reply

    Surely it’s better that rowdy people get alcohol delivered instead of causing trouble in the streets as they make their way to and from a 24 hour shop.

    There are already other companies that deliver alcohol 24 hours but instead of having their own premises, they simply pick up the goods from a shop that already has a 24 hour licence.

    So the refusal to grant a 24 hour alcohol to this company has only reduced competition and encourages people to order from the companies that don’t class their drivers as employees (which many people describe as exploitation).

Leave a Reply

*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.