Disadvantaged children in Brighton and Hove struggle to gain the same qualifications as better off youngsters and next week councillors plan to discuss what to do about it.
They have been sent a report that said: “In general, Brighton and Hove school performance remains strong, outperforming national averages.
“However, the city has a longstanding problem with educational equity: children from more disadvantaged backgrounds tend to perform poorly in comparison to non-disadvantaged children.
“And the both the size of this gap and the attainment of disadvantaged children are worse than national averages.”
Four years ago, Brighton and Hove City Council came up with a strategy to tackle this problem and, the report said, “there have been successful initiatives and partnerships across the life of the strategy.”
But the results show “limited evidence of positive impacts on school attainment, attendance or exclusions”, according to the report.
For the past two years, the council has received the Sutton Trust Fair School Admissions Gold Award for changes aimed at improving outcomes for poorer children.
But while overall GCSE results in Brighton and Hove schools are better than the national average, last year, children eligible for free school meals in Brighton Kemptown and Peacehaven came 527th out of 543 English parliamentary constituencies for educational outcomes.
The council is currently working with researchers to analyse the effects of changes to secondary school admissions rules aimed at helping help children eligible for free school meals.
High absence rates are a problem, with poorer pupils more likely to miss school – and the report to councillors said that attendance was a “critical driver of outcomes”.
The report added: “The impact of absence on academic outcomes is significantly higher for disadvantaged pupils. Even relatively small rates of absence significantly impact on academic outcomes.”
Most local state schools are rated good by Ofsted, with just a handful graded as “requires improvement”.
Traditionally, primary school performance has been a strength but the report said: “We have seen a
dip in outcomes at key stage 2 in 2025.”
Key stage 2 covers years 3 to 6 and ends when children have reached the age of 11.
At GCSE, 47.9 per cent of pupils in Brighton and Hove were awarded the top grades – 9 to 5 – in English and maths compared with the national average of 45.4 per cent.
For disadvantaged children in Brighton and Hove, just 24.6 per cent achieved the benchmark grades 9 to 5. The national average was 25.8 per cent.
The electoral wards with the worst results for all pupils were Woodingdean (28 per cent), Whitehawk and Marina (30 per cent) and Moulsecoomb and Bevendean (31 per cent).
Those with the best results were Westdene and Hove Park (69 per cent), Wish (69 per cent), Goldsmid (62 per cent) and Hollingdean and Fiveways (62 per cent).
Over the past three years the council has made changes to its secondary school admissions rules, initially by giving greater priority to young people eligible for free school meals.
It has redrawn catchment areas and given children in some of the poorer parts of Brighton and Hove a better chance of getting into the most popular schools which have also had better GCSE exam results.
The issue is due to be discussed by the council’s People Overview and Scrutiny Committee at Hove Town Hall at 4pm next Tuesday (29 September). The meeting is scheduled to be webcast.









I’ve always felt the proper answer to this is mentoring.
Some kids just need a different approach – and perhaps more attention – than their hard working parents can often give them.
At the same time, each child needs help and support with the things they are naturally good at – be that practical, sporty, or intellectual. We all have different sides to our brain, and different strengths.
There is a thing where middle class and rich parents can sometimes have more money for extra tuition or for extra school activities, and so that’s why publicly funded after-school clubs are still needed.
As a practical and creative person myself, I can also see why the recent trend to push more people onto the university treadmill is not great – especially at a time when we need more plumbers and electricians.
Current taxation and national insurance changes have also killed off apprenticeships – so that needs a rethink.
One must give credit where it is due. The Council has clearly put considerable thought into making school admissions fairer, and recognition from the Sutton Trust suggests genuine progress has been made.
But admissions can surely only ever be part of the answer.
The rather more uncomfortable sentence in this report is that, after four years of strategy, there remains “limited evidence” of positive impact on attainment, attendance or exclusions.
Perhaps it is time for rather less emphasis on moving children between schools, and rather more relentless focus on ensuring every school can help every child thrive.
That requires genuine partnership too. Listen to headteachers, governors, teachers and parents, particularly when they say something inconvenient. Recent debates over admissions have hardly suggested universal confidence that those voices are always being heard.
And there is a wider lesson here. Political leadership naturally likes initiatives one can announce, consultations one can launch and changes one can point to. Lasting educational improvement is rather less theatrical. It takes years, requires partnership and persistence, and may well bear fruit long after those responsible have moved on to grander stages.
Fair admissions matter. But the real legacy will surely be whether disadvantaged children actually attend more, achieve more and leave school with better opportunities than those who came before them.
One hopes ambition for Brighton and Hove’s children will always exceed ambition for political office.
Lady Bracknell, from the back row of the classroom.