• About
    • Ethics policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Ownership, funding and corrections
    • Complaints procedure
    • Terms & Conditions
  • Contact
  • Support
  • Newsletter
Brighton and Hove News
20 July, 2025
  • News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • Opinion
    • Community
  • Arts and Culture
    • Music
    • Theatre
    • Food and Drink
  • Sport
    • Brighton and Hove Albion
    • Cricket
  • Newsletter
  • Public notices
  • Advertise
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • Opinion
    • Community
  • Arts and Culture
    • Music
    • Theatre
    • Food and Drink
  • Sport
    • Brighton and Hove Albion
    • Cricket
  • Newsletter
  • Public notices
  • Advertise
No Result
View All Result
Brighton and Hove News
No Result
View All Result
Home Brighton

Government paying train firm £38m for ‘disastrous’ performance, according to critical Commons report

by Frank le Duc
Monday 6 Feb, 2017 at 6:53AM
A A
2
New Southern timetable will see 341 more trains cancelled a day

The Department for Transport (DfT) is paying £38 million to train company Govia Thameslink Railway (GTR) despite “disastrous outcomes” over the past year.

The payment is flagged up in a critical report by the House of Commons Transport Committee which spells out shortcomings in the official handling of railway franchises.

The cross-party committee of MPs said that the DfT had “failed to take responsibility for some of the failings in handling the Thameslink, Southern and Great Northern (TSGN) franchise”.

Louise Ellman, who chairs the committee, said: “The government has serious lessons to learn from the management of the TSGN franchise.

“Our committee exposed serious deficiencies in the department’s monitoring and enforcement of this franchise which has already led to a change of policy on performance reporting.

“This can only help to hold serially underperforming operators like GTR to proper account.

“If GTR is officially found to be in breach of contract – and the committee is still pushing ministers for an answer on this – the Department for Transport should consider restructuring the franchise.”

Louise Ellman
Louise Ellman

The report, published yesterday (Sunday 5 February), said: “The department has failed to take responsibility for some of the failings in the handling of the Thameslink, Southern and Great Northern franchise.

“All parties are accountable for the disastrous outcomes on this franchise.

“We do acknowledge that factors were beyond the control of the department, including the significant and inevitable impact of the Thameslink programme enhancements, and industrial relations disputes.

“The department does need to address issues such as inadequate planning, inaccurate assumptions and weak performance incentives.

“We have also exposed serious deficiencies in the department’s monitoring and enforcement of this franchise.

“This exposure led directly to the department changing its policy on performance reporting which is a step in the right direction to holding serially underperforming operators like GTR to proper public account.

“Additionally, the use of a management contract for this franchise, where the department receives fares income and the operator receives a fee for running services, exposes the department financially.

“The net revenue losses for the latest financial year, which amount to at least £38 million, will be met by public funds.

“We believe that serious lessons need to be learned from the GTR issue to prevent similar problems happening in the future when the awarding of a new franchise coincides with a major infrastructure improvement project, the introduction of new technology or the possibility of industrial relations problems.

“If GTR is officially found to be in breach of its contract, the department should consider restructuring the franchise and determine who is best placed to operate it.

“Ultimately any potential restructure should rectify the contractual shortcomings of the current franchise, realigning the incentives and focus of the operator back to the passenger and reducing the financial exposure of the taxpayer.”

trains-at-brighton-station
The report also said: “We were concerned to see that GTR earned a net payment in the first year of operation on the TSGN franchise, with performance rewards greater than penalties.

“We are also disappointed that performance penalties on that franchise have been capped which disincentivises performance once it has deteriorated beyond the breach level.

“We conclude that by capping performance penalties the department has not drawn up a contract in the public interest.

“We recommend that the department learn lessons from this episode and that it overhaul its contracting approach to performance penalties to ensure that penalties are more proportionate to the revenue obtained from a franchise.

“As a starting point, it must no longer contract for a breach level cap on penalties in the way it did so on the TSGN franchise.

“There may be wider issues affecting other franchises but it is difficult for us to make any other specific recommendations as we have only seen performance penalties for the TSGN franchise.

“We are of the view that the department does not have sufficient capacity to revoke a franchise from an operator, particularly of the size and complexity of TSGN.

“With a rather weak penalty regime, the department appears to have very few levers with which to manage performance and enforce a contract.”

ShareTweetShareSendSendShare

Comments 2

  1. Hjarrs says:
    8 years ago

    Profits privatised while the tax payer picks up the losses!

    Reply
  2. Pingback: Government paying Govia Thameslink £38m for ‘disastrous’ performance | Southdown Rise Residents Association

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Most read

Green tile pub owner finally due in court over ripped off tiles

Hire bike users back in the saddle as wheels come off fraud claims

Storm warning with heavy rain and thunder on the way

Seafront main road closed as man throws belongings from flat

Brighton lawyer sold himself dead woman’s house for knockdown price, court told

Lifeboat picks up ill-equipped paddleboarders heading for windfarm at dusk

Drugs trial date set for pair arrested at new Hove flats

Council agrees £7m budget for proposed swimming pool

Council’s budget shortfall will be £40m next year, warns finance chief

Hundreds share their views on how the City Plan should look

Newsletter

Arts and Culture

  • All
  • Music
  • Theatre
  • Food and Drink
Moon Idle headline an awesome night at Brighton’s Alphabet

Moon Idle headline an awesome night at Brighton’s Alphabet

19 July 2025
Council yet to decide which three libraries will close

Community groups urged to save libraries at risk of closure

18 July 2025
Budgie has punters ‘Spellbound’

Budgie has punters ‘Spellbound’

17 July 2025
You aren’t doing it wrong (if no one knows what you are doing)

You Aren’t Doing It Wrong Gets It So Right!

17 July 2025
Load More

Sport

  • All
  • Brighton and Hove Albion
  • Cricket
Sussex Sharks open T20 Blast with a win

Sussex fall short against Surrey at Hove in T20

by Paul Weaver - ECB Reporters Network supported by Rothesay
18 July 2025
0

Sussex Sharks 197-7 (20 overs) Surrey 204-5 (20 overs) Surrey win by seven runs Any remaining hope that Sussex could...

Councillor pleads for Hove leisure centre reopening to go more swimmingly

Council agrees £7m budget for proposed swimming pool

by Sarah Booker-Lewis - local democracy reporter
18 July 2025
5

Senior councillors have backed a £7 million proposal to build a new swimming pool in Brighton. Officials are now expected...

Sussex Sharks open T20 Blast with a win

Sussex return to winning ways in T20 Blast in dramatic style

by Frank le Duc
17 July 2025
0

Gloucestershire 185-5 (20 overs) Sussex Sharks 189-6 (20 overs) Sussex Sharks win by four wickets Danny Lamb held his nerve...

Plans for £6.9m swimming pool go before council cabinet

Plans for £6.9m swimming pool go before council cabinet

by Sarah Booker-Lewis - local democracy reporter
15 July 2025
37

Plans for a new public swimming pool are due to go before Brighton and Hove City Council’s cabinet on Thursday...

Load More
February 2017
M T W T F S S
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728  
« Jan   Mar »

RSS From Sussex News

  • Boy, 17, arrested on suspicion of attempted murder after stabbing 19 July 2025
  • Child sex abuser given 10-year sentence for grooming schoolgirl 18 July 2025
  • Stabbing suspect on the loose after leaving boy, 17, in serious condition 18 July 2025
  • Inquest to open after driver’s death in crash 18 July 2025
  • Death crash PC given court date 17 July 2025
ADVERTISEMENT
  • About
  • Contact
  • Support
  • Newsletter
  • Privacy
  • Complaints
  • Ownership, funding and corrections
  • Ethics
  • T&C

© 2023 Brighton and Hove News

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Opinion
  • Arts and Culture
    • Music
    • Theatre
  • Sport
    • Cricket
  • Newsletter
  • Public notices
  • Advertise
  • About
  • Contact

© 2023 Brighton and Hove News