Previous Story
HMO landlord locked tenants’ bathroom and cut off gas and electricity in revenge for rent arrears
Posted On 18 Apr 2019 at 4:19 pm
74 Ashurst Road
A landlord who put locks on his tenants’ bathroom and cut off their gas and electricity in revenge for rent arrears has ended up with a court bill of almost £2,000.
Amrik Manku, 66, was first reported to Brighton and Hove City Council by one of his five tenants in November last year for not having an HMO licence for the house in Ashurst Road, Moulsecoomb.
And when the council sent Manku a letter informing this was a criminal offence, he started becoming aggressive to his tenants.
Prosecuting for the city council at Brighton Magistrates Court yesterday, Len Batten said: “The officer visited the property on 17 January … and was told that Manku and his son had been aggressive.
“Keypad locks had been fitted to the electricity cupboard and the bathroom to stop the tenants using them until they had cleared their rent arrears.
“The tenants had removed the locks by the time of the visit.
“On 31 January, a member of the public, Jenny, who lived in the adjoining property called and said the previous evening the defendant and his son had removed parts of the boiler, electricity box and front door lock, leaving the property insecure.”
Another visit was made, which confirmed the house was effectively without gas and electricity supply.
The court heard that each of the tenants was charged £5,200 per annum plus bills -bringing Manku £2,166 per month for all five tenants.
Manku, who lives in a five bedroom detached house in Amesbury Crescent worth an estimated £1million, had previously had an HMO licence for the two-storey house but after it expired in November 2017, he failed to renew it.
He said that this was because his daughter, a legal executive, had been responsible for the paperwork on the flat and had since moved abroad.
He added: “Five young men who set upon me, a 66-year-old man, what they have done is aggravated the situation and I can only apologise to the court for my behaviour.
“The tenants also changed the locks, once when I was abroad at the beginning of November and secondly in January. I have a right to inspect the property and any attempt to update the property was not possible because I could not get access.
“They actually barricaded the back door, denying me access and that’s unlawful on their part.”
He pleaded guilty to both charges – having control of an unlicensed HMO, and withdrawing or witholding services reasonably required for the occupation of the premises as a residence.
As the second charge is an unusual one, the bench took legal advice from the court clerk before fining him £460 for each offence, and ordering him to pay £960 in costs and £46 victim surcharge, bringing the total to £1,926.
As it was an unlicensed HMO the tenants can also claim 100% of the rent back that they paid him, as happened in the recent case…
https://www.bbc.co.uk/bbcthree/article/745ea8b2-2ef2-46ee-89ac-3e596b0efeb1
It’s a shame that the article doesn’t give the reasons that the tenants felt they had to stop paying rent.
The conditions that the landlord was making them live in was terrible – leaking sewage onto the bathroom floor, mice, external windows and doors that didn’t lock/shut, thick mould and damp, a leaking kitchen sink to name just a few.
The landlord would also let himself into the property whenever he wanted without prior notice.
The tenants were left with no choice but to withhold rent until the issues were resolved but instead the landlord took away the services, parts from the boiler and the front door lock!
Withholding rent because of a landlord dispute is foolish. Any rent due should always be paid to a responsible person or organisation [i.e. solicitors]so that they do not get into the difficult situation of high debt. The landlord did sound to be a callous money-grabbing chap who failed in maintaining his property; why wasn’t housing assistance or advice given/sought before the property became so squalid?
This does sound a very dodgy story on both sides.