New cafe sees more people coming to Hove Library – but books borrowed still falls

Posted On 28 Jan 2019 at 6:31 pm

More people are visiting Hove Library now a new cafe has opened there – but the number of books being borrowed is continuing to fall.

The library was closed in August last year to convert the basement into a nursery and provide space for Cafe Domenica on the ground floor, changes aimed at making the library more sustainable after plans to move it to Hove Museum were scrapped.

This followed giving over first floor space to the British and Irish Modern Music Institute (BIMM) in spring 2017.

The cafe opened in October, and in November and December, 35,919 people visited the library, including the cafe and BIMM.

This was about 10% more than the 32,717 people who visited in the same two months in 2017 – but fewer than the 36,211 who visited in 2015.

And the number of books borrowed in those two months fell by almost 10% compared to the year before – continuing a downward trend which has seen the number of books borrowed in November and December fall from 26,699 in 2015 to 19,979 in 2018.

A council spokeswoman said: “Hove library figures had been steadily falling year-on-year until Nov/Dec 2018 when they suddenly jumped up again with the introduction of the café.

“The fall in issue figures year-on-year is in keeping with national trends in reductions of borrowing from public libraries.

“However, libraries are much more than just lending books – we are community spaces in which people can meet, socialise, relax and from which we run a range of other services such as access to computers and broadband (which especially helps those who do not have this at home), WiFi provision, Library Connect IT sessions to help people get on-line who are new to it, children’s events like Storytime and Baby Boogie sessions, reading and writing groups, careers advice (in partnership), etc.”

However, library campaigner Chris Hawtree said the decline in borrowing was more down to the range of books offered at Hove now.

He said “I have continually made the point that it is books that bring people into libraries, and we have seen a diminishing stock in Hove’s Carnegie Library, especially in the Fiction section, where – as others say – there is no longer a sense of surprise, the shelves are full of what a Librarian in Brighton called ‘nostalgic chick lit’.

As it is, time and again, interesting books are only supplied to Brighton, and the Carnegie is being regarded as a branch library rather than our town’s central library.

“We very much need to see book selection brought back in house, to librarians, rather than outsourced to the wholesaler Bertrams. There is a great public appetite for books, whose sales are rising while e-books have stagnated, and libraries are not meeting this social need. Libraries are socially resonant at modest cost.

“Speaking for myself, one of life’s joys is to get home with a bagful of books, as I have just done, and loll productively on the sofa – while beside me there is a pot of loose-leaf tea.

“I often hear that there is nobody in the room given to the students from the private music college. This should be brought back into public use.

“Last week at the communities committee I pointed out that readers were told this room would be available to the public anyway during the college holidays and would this please be ensured. I am awaiting a reply to that question as the chair did not know about it.”

The changes were made following a public exhibition to gauge support for a number of potential new public and commercial spaces in Hove Library. The council said the majority of respondents were positive about the proposals.

The work also involved installing new ICT equipment and extra shelving to replace that lost elsewhere, alongside a new mural in the children’s section by illustrator and author Chris Riddell.

The amount of shelving space for books and other stock in the library remains as it was before the refurbishment.

The total cost to the council of the refurbishment work was £87,958. Café Domenica, run by a local charity who work with young adults with learning disabilities, BIMM and Hove Village Day Nursery pay the council a combined annual rent of £38,500 per year.

The improved visitor numbers were announced by the council in a news story on its website last week. No press release was sent to media.

The fall in visitor figures was revealed following a query to the council press office.

  1. Ollie Wilson Reply

    Hove Library is being deliberately starved of book stock to drive borrowing down and make it look like an unpopular library. One of the many tactics to try and close it. In reality it is a lifeline and remains a much used and much loved public facility, one of only two public buildings left in Hove for cultural/educational use, and the only free place to go in bad weather as the museum now charges admission.

  2. Peter Challis Reply

    Interesting comments from library campaigner Christopher Hawtree, but where is the data to support his claims that “There is a great public appetite for books”?

    I’ve looked online and can only find some high level numbers that show relatively minor increases in recent years – see

    As to whether Hove Library is something “special” that requires it to have it’s own purchasing department for the books he wants to be ordered is necessary. Does he have any objective data to support his belief that getting the books that he likes reading on his settee will encourage more books to be borrowed by the general public?

    And if Hove requires it’s own purchasing department then why not for all the city’s libraries?

    The list of services provided by Hove Library is quite impressive – unfortunately it looks like few require shelves filled with books and the result is more of a community centre rather than a library.

    That the unemployed literary elite who loll about with their bags of books drinking leaf tea (and probably listening to vinyl) are still yearning for the old days without understanding that the world has moved on and don’t understand that, maybe, these facilities need a complete review.

    It’s a real shame that the combining of library and museum services only 400 yds away in a combined facility was rejected by the Greens and Conservatives for political reasons rather than looking at what is really needed for the 21st century residents of the city.

  3. geoffbrighton Reply

    *it’s own purchasing department” x 2
    Your misplaced use of the apostrophe suggests to me that perhaps you are a greengrocer!
    Commented by a retired/ unemployed literary elite.

    • Peter Challis Reply

      The embarassment! Good you read and identify the key points of my post – suggest you join me (and other retirees) at

    • Christopher Hawtree Reply

      Good point by geoffbrighton. It is not only it’s/its, but the continually horrent tone taken by Mx Challis suggests that he is suffering from nits.

      • Peter Challis Reply

        Typical vacuous comments from the library campaigner who seem unable provide any facts to support his beliefsz and has to, sadly, resort to pathetic insults.

  4. Peter Challis Reply

    So can you actually respond to my comments or is it just you don’t, sadly, have anything to support the vacuous statements you made to the reporter?

  5. Peter Challis Reply

    So can you actually respond to my comments or is it just that you don’t, typically, have anything to support the vacuous statements you made to the reporter?

  6. Christopher Hawtree Reply

    Out and about with a Petition and struck again by the enthusiasm people show for books in libraries. As I remarked, anybody who goes into City Books or Waterstone’s will find ample stocks of alluring titles, and the places heaving. People want good books – and, indeed, Waterstone’s has stopped selling kindles etc. as books were proving more popular. Nobody can but every book, and many cannot afford any. Well-stocked ibraries are vital.

    One man mentioned that he had been to consult legal volumes in Brighton Library, and was dismayed to find the stock had dwindled.

    And, of course, there is the glorious Oxfam Bookshop on Blatchington Road. One rarely comes out empty-handed. Tremendous staff, and, per square foot, it raises the most money in the South East – and perhaps beyond.

    As another man remarked, words read on paper stay in the mind while so much on the screen becomes a blur.

    A sunny day, such a heartening time, and gainsayers are not a part of it.

    Meanwhile, poor old Worthing, which recently got shot of many books, is set to be a dreaded “hub”, an Orwellian use of language meaning destruction and, mercifully, fended off in Hove.

Leave a Reply


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.