Rivals oppose request by Brighton seafront venue to relax licensing rules
A new venue on Brighton seafront appears to be trying to switch from a place to eat to a drinks-led venue, according those running rival premises.
Shelter Hall, which was trumpeted as Brighton’s first “food hall” by the council, wants to reduce the number of kitchens serving late meals.
It also wants to change its layout in a way that, rivals suggest, would mean it became like a bar full of people drinking alcohol – not all seated and served by waiters.
An anonymous rival wrote to Brighton and Hove City Council objecting to a licensing application by Sessions Market, which runs the rebuilt Shelter Hall, on the seafront opposite the bottom of West Street.
Sessions Market wants variations to some of the licensing conditions that it accepted less than a year ago.
The variations include stripping out 20 tables with waiter service for up to 80 seated customers and allowing people to drink while standing – sometimes referred to as “vertical drinking”.
And Shelter Hall’s promotional material highlights live music and DJs on Friday, Saturday and Sunday evenings for up-and-coming musicians and creative artists.
The rival wrote: “They have DJs playing in the entrance which is hardly befitting for a family, food-led environment.
“Everything about this variation is contrary to the Brighton and Hove licensing plan.
“This is an extremely generous licence already, enabling alcohol to be purchased without food which, for a restaurant premises, is very dubious anyway.”
The rival stopped short of saying that the council had granted the “extremely generous licence” because it owned the freehold to the premises.
But Sussex Police also objected to the council making an exception to its own licensing rules for its own premises, saying: “We do not feel it would be responsible.”
Even the council’s licensing department has written a formal letter of objection which is due to be considered by a licensing panel, made up of three councillors, in the coming week.
The objection letter said: “This is moving away from the original concept of a food-led, seated venue.”
Live music at Shelter Hall on Brighton seafront
At a council licensing panel in June last year Sessions Market’s chief executive Daniel Warne said that Shelter Hall would be a “unique” food-led venue offering the best in food and entertainment. It would, he said, “improve the demographic” of the area.
The council has received eight objections to the application to vary Shelter Hall’s licence conditions, including those from the police and the council licensing department. There have been five letters of support.
Another rival, whose details were redacted by the council, objected to proposed changes to Shelter Hall’s layout, to fewer kitchens serving food in the last hour of trade and to removing tables because it would “encourage vertical drinking” which the existing licence bans.
The objection said: “Permitting vertical drinking at this establishment moves totally away from the premise that this is a ‘food hall’, ie, restaurant with alcohol accompanying food.
“The removal of tables and permitting standing is obviously to encourage vertical drinking.
“I understand that the premises plans to have ‘pre-booked events’ nightly. A pre-booked event is not a private party. It could just be the advertisement of entertainment, therefore by default, this variation turns the venue into a bar.”
Shelter Hall also wants to lift a restriction on its licence so that it can serve drinks in glasses rather than plastic – a move supported by some.
The premises are in the heart of an area that the council has designated a “cumulative impact zone” where drink-related crime and disorder have led the council to adopt stricter policies.
A late submission by Shelter Hall said that Sessions Market wanted the flexibility to help its tenants’ businesses survive while providing “a more civilised and premium offer” on the seafront.
Sessions Market said: “There is absolutely no intention to change the business model, nor transform the premises into a wet-led vertical drinking venue or similar.
“The premises will continue to operate as a food hall controlled by extant licence conditions not subject to change.”
The licensing panel is due to start at 10am on Thursday (29 April) and is scheduled to be webcast on the council website.
LIKE WHAT WE DO? HELP US TO DO MORE OF IT BY DONATING HERE.
And don't forget to sign up to our email newsletter, bringing you the week's biggest stories every Thursday.
It doesn’t really matter what the ‘rivals’ think, what matters is how we came to let our seafront turn into one great big bar.
The new Shelter Hall is a fabulous building and a new landmark, but the deal with the new tenant was to run a food hall – for foodies and for families wanting a broad choice of freshly cooked food.
If this place turns more into a bar – and at the bottom of West Street – the area will start to overflow with drinkers, making it a no go area for families and older people. This is the first section of beach you arrive at if heading into Brighton via the train.
I see they are also suggesting live music is played outside – so this yet more outdoor noise to compete with nearby bars.
Brighton council really need to think this through. The previous tenant in this building was a Gym, which helped to attract a more balanced crowd to the area.
We’d also like to hear from the council when the new toilets are finally opening. These loos were promised for Easter weekend when last mentioned.
This is all utterly inaccurate as is the article’s content…the food hall are seeking a variation to have some tables moveable rather than fixed to allow special events. Incidentally you cannot submit objections to the council anonymously. Sessions business plan is entirely food led with no intentions of running a bar business, here or anywhere else. The existing licence allows for music and drinks service as a natural addition to the package. They have invested substantially in developing food partners and have no desire to reduce the food offering whatsoever. Naturally enough a group of rivals would prefer not to have a popular alternative adjacent, but attempting to block their progress really isn’t the way to ensure they retain customers.
Nice try, Kettles, but the police and council experts have made formal objections on the same grounds.
Sussex Police also objected to the council making an exception to its own licensing rules for its own premises, saying: “We do not feel it would be responsible.”
Even the council’s licensing department has written a formal letter of objection which is due to be considered by a licensing panel, made up of three councillors, in the coming week.
The objection letter said: “This is moving away from the original concept of a food-led, seated venue.”
And as for anonymous objections, perhaps you could look at the council’s report and find their identifying details such as name and address.