Fifty shades of debate as Brighton and Hove councillors are beaten by the budget

Posted On 02 Mar 2015 at 10:18 am

Fifty Shades of Grey dominated a few of the exchanges during the fruitless attempt to set a budget and council tax for Brighton and Hove on Thursday evening (26 February).

Film and book fan Christopher Hawtree, known for his love of literary quotations, said: “Here we have the Green Party. Over there the blue. Over there a sort of shade of red.

“But what we are all enduring is the political equivalent of Fifty Shades of Grey.

“Our hands are tied, politically. We’re under the national lash – and ‘outsourcing’ isn’t the word to get us out of this.

Councillor Christopher Hawtree

Councillor Christopher Hawtree

“Now you might think this metaphor is in poor taste but what I say to you is the national situation is in the worst possible taste.

“Cuts are being felt now, particularly across Hove and Brighton and Portslade.”

Councillor Hawtree said: “Why is all this being done?

“It’s the devolution of blame.

“Nationally they know that people living locally will blame the first level of authority – the council.

“We’ve all heard variants on the phrase ‘the blooming council’ – some rather stronger than that.

“Councillor Mogan mentioned casinos and that brought to mind a phrase – Labour is offering the political equivalent of scampi in the basket.

“It’s the same tawdry fare but they’re trying to disguise it with a bit of wickerwork and a napkin.

“I hear nothing substantial coming forward by way of sustenance.”

Conservative councillor Garry Peltzer Dunn said: “It’s always fun with Councillor Hawtree and his 50 shades of Green.

“It did make me feel that this chamber was your torture chamber.”

And Labour councillor Alan Robins – a paint salesman – said: “With all this talk of shades of greens and greys – I can supply you with any shade of whatever colour you want.”

Councillor Robins also said: “When I first came into this chamber four years ago, I couldn’t have been more nervous.

Councillor Alan Robins

Councillor Alan Robins

“Everywhere I looked there were men and women of great standing in this city – men and women with letters before and after their names, some with buses, streets or blocks of flats named after them.

“I wondered how I could live up to such towering intellects.

“Well, I needn’t have worried. As my dear departed mother would have said: ‘Most haven’t got a bit of common sense between them.’

“We have an administration whose financial spokesman – in an effort to justify a 5.9 (per cent) increase in council tax – tells hard-working people, some having to work 40 or 50 hours a week just to stand still, in all seriousness and without a trace of irony: ‘Don’t worry. You’ll only have to give up one grapefruit a week.’

“And a Tory opposition who can’t decide among themselves if they want Big Eric to come down and sort things out or not.

“It gives me no pleasure to say this is the most disliked administration I have ever known.

“Everywhere I go, everyone I speak to, the first thing they say to you is: ‘When can we get rid of the Greens?’

“It’s almost a citywide mantra.

“So you might suppose that they would have tried to salvage something from this shipwreck.

“But no, the same old things – increase parking charges, shut more toilets.

“In the course of my work I have to use on-street parking about five times a day.

“It’s a minimum of £1 a time. Twenty working days a month means £100 a month – £1,200 a year.

“Any increase could finish a small business and we cannot afford to deter visitors from outside the city from coming to Brighton because of the cost of parking.

“We’re asking a lot of small business and tradesmen to rebuild the economy and take on apprentices and train the next generation so we’re proposing to help support them by freezing on-street parking and traders’ permits.

“(With) any increase in parking charges, we add more costs to running the small businesses which we’re relying on to rebuild our economy.”

One of those present said that he appeared to have made the comments without even being required to by his party whip.

  1. feline1 Reply

    What a load of bollocks. Just make a decision you can justify and stick to it. Show some leadership. Instead of just blocking people on Twitter.

  2. Christopher Hawtree Reply

    This part of my speech has excited some.

    However, my key point was that tory cllr Ann Norman referred to “these difficult circumstances”. In those three words she revealed an apparent split between the local Conservatives and the Government. The latter has repeatedly said that these cuts to local-government funding are necessary for national recovery. So, by that logic, cllr Norman should have said “these wonderful circumstances”. But she didn’t. So there we have it: the Conservative party is divided.

    Say so myself, I thought my coining “the devolution of blame” is nifty. It came to mind on a stroll. As these things do.

Leave a Reply


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.