Court lands shared house owner with £10k bill

Posted On 05 Dec 2020 at 12:50 pm

The owner of a property in Brighton has been landed with a fine and court costs totalling almost £10,000 for turning the family home into a shared house and renting it out.

Shirley White, 56, divided up the house, 41 Bevendean Crescent, and started renting it out before learning that she needed planning permission to convert it into a “house in multiple occupation” (HMO).

White applied to Brighton and Hove City Council for planning permission but her planning application was refused and enforcement action began shortly after.

She appealed against the refusal but the Planning Inspectorate upheld the council’s decision.

The council issued an enforcement notice but White, of Friars Walk, north London, let out the property as a shared house again.

As a result, the council took legal action, bringing the case to Brighton Magistrates’ Court.

The council said that White was fined £7,830 and ordered to pay £2,003 in costs, making £9,833 in total.

Councillor Leo Littman, who chairs the council’s Planning Committee, said: “Planning permission is there for a reason.

“It helps to ensure that the people who are going to live in shared housing have decent living space as well as taking into account potential pressures on neighbourhoods.

“This decision sends a strong message that although we will always try to resolve planning issues through negotiation, if the rules are consistently broken we will resort to legal action.”

The council said: “HMOs provide essential low-cost accommodation for people living and working in a city where rents are high.

“Our planning policies are not designed to stop HMOs. They help us to manage HMO concentrations across the city and maintain balanced and sustainable communities, as well as ensuring decent living standards.”

  1. Stephen Hetherington Reply

    A certain individual and his wife who had 50 odd HMO’s would buy houses and furnish them to HMO requirements and then sell them to amateur landlords in the knowledge they could never get a licence.
    The deal being that BHCC has to wait for the appeal to fail before the HMO becomes liable for court action resulting in a fine. As it takes so long for the refusal to be final the rent has come in and the house has goes up in value to be sold on at a profit
    I would like to know how many years this case went on for, several years? Ms white pushed her luck
    too far.

  2. Hendra Reply

    Great to hear the wise words of Cllr Littman. Perhaps he could wax lyrical about the planning for the i360?

  3. Nigel Furness Reply

    YES! Hendra.
    Have you noticed how, whenever comments are posted on the i360, ALL the ‘Green’ Councillors, without exception, are suddenly struck dumb—such a stark contrast to their customary obsession for self-publicising FANTASIES?
    But fear not—They WON’t get away with their wicked work!

  4. Greens Out Reply

    The same woman that was fined over £18k earlier this year?

Leave a Reply


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.