• About
    • Ethics policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Ownership, funding and corrections
    • Complaints procedure
    • Terms & Conditions
  • Contact
  • Support
  • Newsletter
Brighton and Hove News
5 June, 2023
  • News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • Opinion
    • Community
  • Music
  • Theatre
  • Sport
    • Brighton and Hove Albion
    • Cricket
  • Public notices
  • Advertise
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • Opinion
    • Community
  • Music
  • Theatre
  • Sport
    • Brighton and Hove Albion
    • Cricket
  • Public notices
  • Advertise
No Result
View All Result
Brighton and Hove News
No Result
View All Result
Home Brighton

Woman criticises confusing Brighton bus gate signs

by Sarah Booker-Lewis - local democracy reporter
Saturday May 27, 23 at 12:05AM
in Brighton, Hove, News, Politics, Transport
40
Woman criticises confusing Brighton bus gate signs

The approach to the Marlborough Place bus gate

A woman who received a fine for driving through a “bus gate” in Brighton said that the signs “don’t make sense”.

Mary Glossop*, 54, received two fines over the weekend of Saturday 11 March and Sunday 12 March.

She drove through the bus gate at Marlborough Place, in the Valley Gardens area of Brighton, while taking her partner to a writers’ workshop at the One Church, in Gloucester Place.

Driving into town from the couple’s home in Hove is essential, she said, because her partner Jimmers, 46, is a blue badge holder and cannot walk more than 50 metres, making a bus journey impossible.

And it was the first time that the Writers HQ had held an in-person event since the first coronavirus pandemic lockdown in 2020.

The couple had not travelled into Valley Gardens for three years and were not aware of the changes to the road layout.

Mr Glossop used to live in Gloucester Place and the couple took their familiar route, only to receive a fine days later.

Mrs Glossop said: “I was following the signs. It says local access and went into Marlborough Place.

“When you reach the bus gate at the end of Marlborough Place, there was nowhere to go.

“All you can do is turn right and around Old Steine again. There’s no way to get to One Church other than going around the houses, which doesn’t make sense.

“If I went up Church Street, that takes me into the most pedestrianised part of Brighton, a one-way system and the narrowest part of town.

“The argument that it’s improving green space and anti-congestion doesn’t make sense. It’s busy stop-start driving and terrible for pollution. It’s more congested, pushing traffic up the one-way streets.

“When you reach the bus gate at the end of Marlborough Place, there was nowhere to go. You have to go over it.

“It’s too confusing and it’s dangerous because you’ve got no time or preparation to make a manoeuvre.”

Mrs Glossop called for improvements to signs to explain what “local traffic” means and more publicity on the council’s social media and Visit Brighton to tell people the routes they must take to avoid bus gates.

In the two years since the Marlborough Place and Gloucester Place bus gate went live, the number of drivers passing through has fallen.

In the first year, the highest number of drivers passing through the gates was 5,570 in August 2021. Numbers dropped to 1,687 in August 2022.

Last year there was a significant fall in the number of vehicles passing through the bus gate, with a high of 2,217 in January and a low of 1,088 last October.

Brighton and Hove City Council said that 67 per cent, more than two thirds of penalty charges, were issued to vehicles registered outside the BN postcode area.

*Mary Glossop is a pseudonym.

ShareTweetShareSendSendShare
ADVERTISEMENT

Comments 40

  1. Dave says:
    1 week ago

    It’s fairly moronic it doesn’t just say bus lane like every other city.
    The term bus gate is just a made up term to catch people out. And the figures show clearly that people who know the area avoid it, people who don’t know the area are getting fined. 1000+ fines a month shows clearly there is a signage issue.

    Reply
    • Andy says:
      1 week ago

      You need to get out more Dave, there are bus gates in loads of UK cities these days

      Reply
    • Maurice says:
      1 week ago

      Burning stuff creates pollution. Old diesel vehicles cause much more pollution than petrol vehicles. Congestion is pollution, free flowing traffic is slightly less pollution.
      She is the congestion.
      She says bus gates are ‘terrible for pollution’ but she is incorrect. Diesel is the pollution and pollution harms our health.
      She is upset she didn’t see or understand a common sign in cities and got caught. End of story.

      Reply
    • mart Burt says:
      1 week ago

      Dave
      It doesn’t say bus lane because it’s not a dedicated bus lane as other vehicles need access to properties and side roads.

      The term bus gate is used in various Towns and Cities across the country and is nothing new.
      While Gate might be confusing to some, surely the word BUS should ring alarm bells and therefore more attention is needed by drivers.
      Entering from the Old Steine and passing the King and Queen there are various signs informing drivers they MUST turn right at the traffic lights. If these signs are missed, there are BLUE signs with a white Arrow showing traffic to turn right. There’s even a repeater sign on the traffic lights themselves, I do worry that drivers who look at the lights can’t see the right turn in front of their faces.

      I think the problem is the wording ‘Local’ Traffic. Those who are travelling through are not ‘local’, local in this case would be as I said above access to local residents, businesses and side roads.

      Reply
      • Bhcc road planning says:
        7 days ago

        There isn’t a gate. Change it. End of story.

        Reply
        • Benjamin says:
          5 days ago

          You need to revise your Traffic Signs Manual if that’s what you truly believe, because you’re completely incorrect.

          Reply
          • mart Burt says:
            5 days ago

            Benjamin
            Not sure if you’re comment was aimed at me.
            I’m fully aware of the meaning of traffic signs and have no need to check the Traffic Signs Manual.

  2. Benjamin says:
    1 week ago

    It’s one of Brighton’s top earners from the data I’ve seen. I’ve also been caught out by that gate as well. More difficult because I also have to remember what vehicle I’m driving of a day.

    Reply
    • Benjamin says:
      5 days ago

      £2.4million from the ones in York and Gloucester since January 2021.

      Reply
  3. Still drinking Phelims tears says:
    1 week ago

    I’m old enough to remember a thriving London Rd being two way traffic. People came into the town, spent their money and then went home happy. I believe the original changes that started London Rd on the slippery slope break the third world hell hole it currently is happened under a Labour administration.

    Reply
    • Benjamin says:
      5 days ago

      London Road still is two-way traffic. Traffic goes both ways, that’s the very definition of two-way traffic. Semantic sarcasm aside, the decline of the highstreets has been pretty much majority contributed to the advent of the internet.

      White, J., Hickie, J., Jackson, C., Orr, A. and Richardson, R. (2023). The experience economy in UK city centres: a multidimensional and interconnected response to the ‘death of the high street’? – White Rose Research Online. Whiterose.ac.uk.

      ‌

      Reply
      • mart Burt says:
        5 days ago

        Benjamin
        Incorrect, London Road is not TWO WAY.
        You can only go North from St Peters Church.
        You can not enter London Road coming South from Preston Circus you are directed along Viaduct Road then Ditchling road where you can enter London Road via a side road. Once in London Road you still can’t exit to go South, therefore the Road is not two way as South bound is limited access and in not a through road.

        Reply
        • Benjamin says:
          4 days ago

          Knew you’d say that. So it’s two way, as you just accurately described.

          Reply
  4. Matt says:
    1 week ago

    Even if you don’t understand the term “bus gate” there’s a standard blue sign with a picture of a bus and the word “only” right there. I do think they should just change the road marking to “bus lane” as it’s needlessly specific and technical and clearly people don’t looks at the sign next to it

    Reply
    • Benjamin says:
      5 days ago

      It is causing confusion, the revenue generated by fines are testament to that most definitely! However, it is a standard term that is used in the Traffic Signs Manual, a book that every driver with a license has signed to keep up to date on.

      Reply
  5. Hendrik says:
    1 week ago

    pseudonym

    Reply
  6. Jackson Field says:
    1 week ago

    Bhcc Transport Dept – for ever looking for new ways to screw the motorist. The department needs serious scrutiny

    Reply
  7. Pseudonym says:
    1 week ago

    This particular bus gate is made worse by the fact that cars coming down North Road are allowed to turn left, which means drivers coming towards the bus gate from Marlborough Place can see non restricted traffic i.e. normal cars, heading towards the church, literally 20 feet in front of them, on the other side of a small 10ft by 10ft box painted on the road.

    I missed the sign on the left, a few feet before it, advising me of the gate because a delivery lorry had parked in front of it. I think this is a deceptive practice, clearly intended to raise money rather than serve any real purpose.

    Reply
    • Ian Tommins says:
      1 week ago

      Which is precisely why the sign says bus gate rather than bus lane.

      Reply
    • Benjamin says:
      5 days ago

      People are unfamiliar with Bus Gates, and that’s where the confusion comes in, and as you say, they see another car going that way and follow without thinking. Considering the lack of upheld appeals, the law courts seem to agree with this assessment.

      Reply
      • mart Burt says:
        5 days ago

        Benjamin
        So the word gate is confusing, perhaps but the word BUS should alert drivers straight away should it not ?
        A common Blue Signs with arrows that give orders can’t be mistaken.
        Trouble is drivers don’t look at the signs, how many have been caught speeding by the camera’s that are painted bright yellow and clearly in the drivers view?
        It is worrying really when you look at the no1 cause of road traffic crashes, lack of observations so I’m not surprised people get caught out.

        Reply
        • Benjamin says:
          3 days ago

          I agree with this Mart, been behind a car several times in a nee naw with all my blues and twos going, and it’s not until 20 minutes later they react. Observations are definitely not a strong point for many drivers I’ve experienced.

          Reply
  8. Christopher Le Gallez says:
    1 week ago

    Don’t go to Brighton.

    Reply
  9. Austin says:
    1 week ago

    North Street one end, London Road the other. A few tens of metres of unencumbered bus travel bounded by congestion each end. Pointless other than the revenue opportunity. But then we all knew this.

    Reply
    • Ian Tommins says:
      1 week ago

      It’s to stop through traffic from using that side of valley gardens, while still allowing access for the residents and businesses.

      Reply
      • Austin says:
        1 week ago

        Yes, pointless other than the revenue opportunity.

        Reply
  10. Vince says:
    1 week ago

    The signs are easily obscured by buses. They could have used the typical and traditional No Entry sign with ‘Except Buses, Bikes and Taxis’ beneath. But then they’d see this revenue stream totally collapse.
    BTW. What’s so special about taxis? Most of those I see speeding down Western Road have no passenger.

    Reply
    • Benjamin says:
      3 days ago

      Taxis are public transport, isn’t they Vince?

      Reply
  11. Nathan Adler says:
    1 week ago

    London districts have an electronic system that allows blue badge users to access bus gates without being fined. Brighton Council claimed this was not possible. Perhaps the new Labour administration could get this sorted.

    Reply
    • mart Burt says:
      1 week ago

      Nathan Adler
      Electronic System ?
      How does that work then ?

      Reply
      • Nathan Adler says:
        1 week ago

        Digital blue badge system existing along side the standard blue badge.

        Reply
        • Local Person says:
          1 week ago

          Nathan, you need to remember that the Greens did not like disabled people as they need to use cars to get around. If you are not on a bike, then you were potential revenue to the Greens.

          Don’t ask for sensible solutions that would benefit a car owner.

          All cars need to be pushed into traffic jams to kick out more fumes – as was pointed out in the article. So many of the Green anti-car policies are also anti-environment as they cause more fumes.

          Reply
        • mart Burt says:
          1 week ago

          Nathan Adler
          Never heard of that so thanks for the information.

          Reply
    • Benjamin says:
      5 days ago

      My first thought is that Blue Badge holders are generally not entitled to exemption from bus gates as with other forms of moving traffic offences.

      Reply
  12. S says:
    1 week ago

    The greens not green have screwed this city into the ground by being disablist, cycle loving prats. They would be a bit buggered if they had there way & got rid of all the vehicles when they need an emergancy plumber ect, cant see many trades ppl going to a job on the bus. The bus gate is to catch ppl out to make money that got spent on cycle lanes that are hardly used, bike sheds over 2 parking spaces when all the houses around some of the areas have gardens & 1 of the most expensive resin paths going & dont get me started on putting concrete blocks around tree bases so if the wind does topple the tree theres going to be bits of flying concrete aswell. THERE OUT NOW. No one can do any worse than the greens.

    Reply
  13. Rostrum says:
    1 week ago

    It’s a cash cow. Everyone knows it. Dishonest and only there in it’s current form to generate cash and dissuade people from ever returning

    Reply
  14. rod garty says:
    1 week ago

    I wont go anywhere near that area any more ,so confusing ,what is local traffic ??? I keep well clear of that whole area

    Reply
  15. Martin says:
    6 days ago

    It’s remarkable that people openly offer this as their reason when caught driving illegally: “I hadn’t driven there in 3 years, so I just drove from memory without paying attention to any new layout or signage.”

    Reply
  16. Vince says:
    5 days ago

    Strangers are being caught out by out of date satellite navigation systems too. It’s difficult enough finding your way around an unfamiliar town without crafty councils resorting to this kind of money raiser. I hope someone with the means to challenge this obviously flawed ‘gate’ in the courts. It would be a delight to see the courts ordering the fines to be repaid.
    There is precedent: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/02/02/council-refunds-106000-fines-drivers-complaints-road-sign-high/
    Better yet if the individuals responsible for persevering with this in the certain knowledge that thousands of people do not deliberately incur fines were personally surcharged. Too much to hope for, I suppose.

    Reply
    • Benjamin says:
      3 days ago

      Yeah Vince, my old one still suggests driving through the middle in some sort of off roading scenario. I would say people wouldn’t do that, but I remember a story a few years back where people where following their satnavs into a river.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Most read

Brighton Carnival cancelled

Brighton and Hove drug dealer jailed for four years

School kids to swim for free at Saltdean Lido

Brighton man wanted over 12-car crash on A27

Stripey beach hut trailer can stay after council drops legal action

Parking zone proposal splits residents

Hove store faces battle over plan to sell drink until 5am

Slap on the bum lands cyclist in sex offenders register

Bowls club faces rematch with planners over proposed revamp

Seafront café owners await verdict on revamp plan

Arts and Culture

  • All
  • Music
  • Theatre
Brighton Carnival cancelled

Brighton Carnival cancelled

4 June 2023
Bad news: SLANT call it a day. Good news: SLANT announce farewell gig

Bad news: SLANT call it a day. Good news: SLANT announce farewell gig

3 June 2023
Jake Shears certainly wasn’t the ‘Last Man Dancing’ in Brighton last night

Jake Shears certainly wasn’t the ‘Last Man Dancing’ in Brighton last night

2 June 2023
Model/Actriz announce Brighton gig at Club Revenge

Model/Actriz announce Brighton gig at Club Revenge

2 June 2023
Load More

Sport

  • All
  • Brighton and Hove Albion
  • Cricket
Sussex Sharks open T20 Blast with a win

Glamorgan demolish Sussex Sharks in T20 at Hove

by Will Symons
4 June 2023
0

Chasing a mammoth 220 to win, the Sharks fell 32 runs short as Glamorgan won a thrilling fixture at the...

Sussex Sharks open T20 Blast with a win

Sussex Sharks lose by 10 wickets after a jam in Hampshire

by Alex Smith
3 June 2023
0

Sussex Sharks 144 lost to Hampshire Hawks 145-0 by 10 wickets Ben McDermott proved that the Hampshire Hawks are more...

Southern Vipers thrash Thunder by eight wickets at Hove

Vipers contained by Sparks in Charlotte Edwards Cup thriller

by Brian Halford
3 June 2023
0

Central Sparks retained their slender hopes of Charlotte Edwards Cup qualification with a thrilling seven-run victory win over Southern Vipers...

Bowls club faces rematch with planners over proposed revamp

Bowls club faces rematch with planners over proposed revamp

by Sarah Booker-Lewis - local democracy reporter
1 June 2023
3

A bowls club faces a rematch with planners as revised proposals to refurbish its facilities come up for consideration next...

Load More
ADVERTISEMENT
  • About
  • Contact
  • Support
  • Newsletter
  • Privacy
  • Complaints
  • Ownership, funding and corrections
  • Ethics
  • T&C

© 2023 Brighton and Hove News

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • Opinion
    • Community
  • Music
  • Theatre
  • Sport
    • Brighton and Hove Albion
    • Cricket
  • Public notices
  • Advertise

© 2023 Brighton and Hove News

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.