Neighbours said that they were worried about the prospect of noise coming from a Brighton café after the owner applied for a drinks licence.
Andrew Marcantonio, 38, applied to Brighton and Hove City Council for a licence to sell alcohol at Nowhere Man, in Upper North Street, Brighton.
Sussex Police initially lodged an objection but withdrew it after Mr Marcantonio agreed to a number of conditions were a licence to be granted.
He agreed to restrict the sale of alcohol to people seated at tables and served by waiting staff – and he agreed that the premises should offer substantial food at all times.
A council licensing panel – made up of three councillors – considered the application today (Thursday 4 January).
If the panel approves the application, Nowhere Man is expected to be permitted to sell alcohol from 9am to 10pm every day.
This would be earlier than the 11pm originally requested but it would mean that the hours complied with council licensing policy. And there would be no off-sales.
After reading neighbours’ concerns about noise before the licensing panel hearing, Mr Marcantonio offered to close the rear patio area to customers at 5pm each day.
Neighbour Richard Taylor told the panel: “It’s a big courtyard and it’s very noisy. Our concern is every evening is going to be very noisy for us and that would be hugely detrimental.
“The front of the café has spill-over into the street which can be an issue for us.”
Mr Marcantonio’s solicitor Piers Warne said that when the back garden closed at 5pm, smokers would be sent to the front.
Mr Warne said: “Andrew has been there nine years or so and has built up a reputation across Brighton. He’s famous for his pancakes and bagels.
“He hosts community events including craft sessions, which are variously themed, drawing classes and events on a very small scale with local acts.
“Early doors there were some mistakes made with events that caused noise. Hands are held up. Customers used the outside area where music was playing.
“When environmental protection raised the issue, Andrew reacted and we’ve not had any complaints for six years.”
One of the panel members, Councillor Andrei Czolak, asked if there were plans to host “bottomless brunches”.
What is it with those who choose to live in a vibrant city centre but then object to all that which makes the area vibrant.?
That’s the centre of town. I bet the concerned neighbours are more than happy to visit a licensed premises 50 metres away next to someone else’s back yard. Serving wine with lunch will not suddenly make this a noisy place there are a bunch of pubs a stones throw from it. People need to get a grip and support businesses that make their area special.
I am far from Upper North Street Brighton. My opinion is not to allow selling alcohol.
I don’t think noise objections tend to succeed of memory serves?